Introduction
Many energy systems rely on water to absorb and transfer thermal energy. Many power plants use water to produce steam or remove excess heat, while some data centers use water-based cooling systems to prevent equipment from overheating.
In this investigation, students will compare how water and air respond to heating and cooling. By collecting and analyzing temperature data, students will explore how water behaves as it gains and loses thermal energy and connect their observations to real-world energy systems.
Student Objectives
Students will be able to
- Collect and analyze temperature data during heating and cooling.
- Compare temperature changes in water and an exposed air temperature probe during heating and cooling.
- Identify patterns in temperature change over time.
- Explain how water absorbs and releases thermal energy during heating and cooling.
- Connect experimental evidence to cooling systems used in power plants and data centers.
- Evaluate environmental impacts associated with water use for cooling.
Materials (per group)
- Student Handout
- 1 beaker (200 mL)
- Water (150 mL)
- 2 digital probe thermometers
- Heat lamp
- Duct tape
- Cardboard or paper cup
- Timer or stopwatch
- Graphing paper or digital graphing tool
Procedure
- Make a Prediction
- Divide students into groups of 2 or 3, and provide them with the Student Handout.
- Ask students: “Which material will change temperature more slowly: water or air?”
- Students record a prediction and explain their reasoning.
- Set Up the Investigation (Each Group)
- Fill the beaker with 150 mL of water.
- Use tape to secure one temperature probe in the water, positioning the tip about halfway between the surface and the bottom of the beaker. Make sure the probe does not touch the bottom or sides of the beaker.
- Place the beaker and probe beneath a heat lamp, but do not turn it on yet. Position the heat lamp a safe distance (at least 12-18 inches) from the beaker. Check the specific manufacturer’s safety requirements.
- Use half of a paper cup or a cardboard block as a stand to position the second temperature probe next to the beaker, also beneath the heat lamp. Position the tip at approximately the same height as the water probe, making sure it does not touch any surfaces.
- Measure and record the starting temperature of the water and air before turning on the heat lamp.

- Collect Data
- Turn on the heat lamp.
- Measure and record the temperature of the water and air every 2 minutes for 10 minutes.
- After 10 minutes, turn off the heat lamp, but do not move the beaker or temperature probes.
- Continue recording both temperatures every 2 minutes for an additional 10 minutes.
- Analyze the Results
- Students graph temperature changes over time, and complete analysis questions in the Student Handout.
- Explain to students that cooling systems work by absorbing and transferring heat away from machines and equipment. Encourage students to use evidence from their data to explain how water’s response to heating and cooling helps make it useful in cooling systems.
- Teacher Note: Students will likely observe that the water temperature changes more gradually than the air probe reading. Because the air probe is directly exposed to the heat lamp, some of its temperature increase may result from absorbing radiation directly. This investigation illustrates different temperature responses but does not provide a controlled comparison of the thermal properties of water and air.
- Students will construct a CER (Claim, Evidence, Reasoning) explanation for what makes water useful for cooling systems in power plants and data centers.
- Connect to Real Systems
- Have students choose one of the following systems to investigate in connection to water usage:
- a power plant (natural gas, coal, nuclear, geothermal, etc.)
- a data center
- Students should research how water is used as a cooling system in their chosen technology and identify possible environmental impacts of that water use.
- Encourage students to consider:
- where the water comes from
- why cooling is necessary
- how water absorbs or transfers heat
- what happens to the water after use
- how cooling systems may affect ecosystems, rivers, or local water supplies
Answer Key
Part 1: Make a Prediction: Student predictions will vary.
Part 2: Heating Investigation: Answers will vary. Students should generally observe that water temperature increases more gradually than the air probe reading.
Part 3: Cooling Investigation: Answers will vary. Students should generally observe that the air probe reading changes more quickly than the water temperature.
Part 4: Looking for Patterns:
- Sample answer: The water’s temperature increased gradually during heating and decreased gradually during cooling. Its temperature did not change as quickly as the air temperature.
- Sample answer: The air probe reading changed more quickly. It increased faster during heating and decreased faster during cooling.
- Sample answer: The water temperature changed more slowly than the air probe reading during both heating and cooling.
- Sample answer: The water temperature changed more gradually during both heating and cooling, while the air probe reading changed more quickly. This suggests that water and the exposed air probe responded differently to heating and cooling in this investigation.
Part 5: Analyze the Results
- Expected answer: The air probe reading increased more quickly than the water temperature. Students should cite specific temperature changes from their data.
- Expected answer: The air probe reading decreased more quickly than the water temperature. Students should cite specific temperature changes from their data.
- Expected answer: The water temperature decreased more gradually than the air probe reading. Students should support their answer with their own data.
- Sample answer: The temperature of the water increased relatively gradually as thermal energy was transferred to it. This suggests that water can absorb thermal energy without undergoing a rapid increase in temperature.
- Note for Teacher: Water has a relatively high specific heat capacity, meaning that a substantial amount of energy is required to raise its temperature.
- Sample answer: Water can absorb thermal energy while undergoing a relatively gradual increase in temperature. Once heated, the water can flow away from the equipment, carrying thermal energy with it and transferring that energy elsewhere in the cooling system.
- Answers will vary.
Part 6: Explain the Evidence: Answers will vary.
Claim Sample Response: Water is useful in cooling systems because it can absorb thermal energy without heating up quickly.
Evidence Sample Response: During the investigation, the water temperature increased from 24.6°C to 28.4°C, a change of 3.8°C. The air probe temperature increased from 26.6°C to 35.8°C, a change of 9.2°C. The water also cooled more gradually after the heat lamp was turned off. Students should incorporate specific measurements from their own data when possible.
Reasoning Sample Response: Water’s gradual temperature increase shows that it can absorb thermal energy without quickly becoming much hotter. In power plants and data centers, water can absorb thermal energy from equipment and carry it away as it flows through a cooling system. This helps prevent equipment from overheating.
Part 7: Investigating Real Systems
Student responses will vary depending on the system and sources selected. The following are key ideas students may identify if choosing a power plant to research.
- Many power plants produce large amounts of heat. Cooling systems remove excess thermal energy and help the power plant operate effectively.
- Water is circulated through parts of the cooling system where it absorbs thermal energy. The heated water then carries that thermal energy away.
- Depending on the power plant, cooling water may come from rivers, lakes, reservoirs, oceans, groundwater, municipal wastewater, or other sources.
- This depends on the cooling system. Some systems return water to its source after it has been warmed. Other systems recirculate the water through cooling towers, where some of the water evaporates as heat is released.
- Large water withdrawals can affect the amount of water available to ecosystems and other users. Returning warmer water can also change aquatic habitats. Cooling systems may also lose water through evaporation.
Making Connections: Answers will vary.
Sample Response: Using a phone depends on systems beyond the phone itself. Apps, websites, videos, and online services rely on data centers, which require electricity and produce heat. Water may be used to cool the data centers directly, and it may also be used by power plants that generate their electricity. In some locations, that water can come from rivers. This means an everyday action on a phone can be connected to water and energy systems far away.