Introduction

In this activity, you’ll take on the role of a stakeholder in a simulated town hall about a local decision related to nuclear energy. Your group will research, develop a position, and engage in a structured discussion with other community members to evaluate the risks, benefits, and trade-offs of a proposed action.

Learning Objectives

By the end of this simulation, you will be able to:

1. Evaluate multiple perspectives on nuclear energy by analyzing stakeholder viewpoints and trade-offs.
2. Develop and defend a structured, evidence-based argument based on your assigned stakeholder’s role and priorities.
3. Collaborate and engage in respectful, civil discourse to explore complex community decisions.
4. Reflect on how values, evidence, and identity influence real-world policy and science decisions.

Simulation Overview

You will:

1. Be assigned to a stakeholder group (e.g., Local Resident, Nuclear Engineer, Health Official).
   
2. Collaborate with your group to research or discuss what your stakeholder’s position might be.
   
3. Use this handout to organize your evidence, concerns, and talking points.
   
4. Participate in a moderated town hall discussion.
   
5. Vote and reflect on your learning at the end of the activity.

Group Planning Sheet

Stakeholder Group:

Group Members:

1. What are your stakeholder’s top concerns?

2. What are the potential benefits of the proposal for your group?

3. Is your group in favor, opposed, or undecided about the proposal?

❑ In Favor ❑ Opposed ❑ Undecided

Explain why:

4. What evidence or examples will support your position?

5. What conditions (if any) would make your group more likely to support the proposal?

6. What might other stakeholders argue, and how will you respond?

During the Town Hall

• Designate 1–2 spokespersons to present your group’s views.
• Listen actively and take notes during the discussion.
• Be respectful, stick to your role, and use evidence to support your statements.

Vote

After the discussion, cast your individual vote on the proposal:

❑ Support ❑ Oppose ❑ Undecided

Reflection

Answer the following after the town hall:

1. What was your group’s stance? Explain why.

2. Did any group make you reconsider your position? Why or why not?

3. What was challenging about speaking for a role that may not match your personal opinion?

4. How do you think real-life decisions about energy and the environment are influenced by stakeholder perspectives?

Assessment Rubric